Reproduction in Vertebrates, Grade 12: Ovipary to Vivipary, the Amniotic Egg and Four Corrections

The photograph at the top of this topic is an ostrich leading a brood of chicks, and the topic never uses it.

That bird answers three of the five things the topic is about. Ostrich chicks are precocial. They are guarded by both parents, and the male incubates the eggs at night. It is the best example in the topic and it is sitting there as decoration.

This page gives the five parts of the topic properly, with South African examples that do the teaching, and four places where the printed account is too absolute to be true.

Where this fits in the curriculum

Subject Life Sciences
Grade 12
Term 1
Topic Topic 3, Reproduction in vertebrates
Structure One unit, five sections: types of fertilisation, development of the embryo, the amniotic egg, precocial and altricial development, parental care
Status No formally assessed practical. This is a reading and comparison topic
Marks Our worksheet is 50

This page sells you nothing

There is no apparatus in this topic and we are not going to invent any. Nothing to pick, nothing to refill. The topic is taught with examples, and the best examples in South Africa are free to look up.

Types of fertilisation

External Internal
Where Outside the female's body, in water Inside the female's body
How Sperm and eggs are released into the water The male deposits sperm into the female
Who Most fish and amphibians Reptiles, birds, mammals
Numbers Very many eggs, because most are never fertilised or are eaten Far fewer eggs, because the chance of fertilisation is high
Dependence on water Total. The gametes dry out in air None, which is what allowed vertebrates to breed on dry land

The comparison question is nearly always about numbers. External fertilisation needs enormous numbers of eggs because the chance of any one being fertilised is low. Internal fertilisation needs few because the chance is high. Say the chance, not just the number.

Development of the embryo: three strategies

Strategy Where the embryo develops Where the food comes from Examples
Ovipary Outside the female's body, in a laid egg The yolk Fish, amphibians, most reptiles, all birds
Ovovivipary Inside the female's body The yolk, not the mother Some reptiles and some sharks
Vivipary Inside the female's body The mother, through a placenta or equivalent Mammals, some shark species

Ovovivipary and vivipary differ in one thing only: where the food comes from. Both develop inside the mother. If a learner writes that the difference is the location, the mark is gone. The difference is nourishment.

The amniotic egg, and why it mattered

Birds and reptiles lay amniotic eggs. The amniotic egg is what let vertebrates stop breeding in water, which is the single biggest thing in this topic.

Part What it does
Porous shell Allows gaseous exchange between the embryo and the air, while holding the contents in
Yolk sac Food for the developing embryo
Amnion Encloses the amniotic fluid, which protects the embryo from shock and from drying out
Allantois Stores waste products
Chorion Allows gaseous exchange

The mammalian foetus has the same structures under different names. The amnion and amniotic fluid are still there; the placenta takes over what the yolk sac, allantois and chorion do in an egg.

Finding 1: three membranes or four

You will read that "three membranes inside the amniotic egg help the embryo to develop", and in the line immediately above, that "a yolk sac provides food for developing embryos".

The yolk sac is itself one of the extraembryonic membranes. The standard count is four: yolk sac, amnion, allantois and chorion. Listing the yolk sac separately and then saying three leaves a learner unable to tell what to write when a question asks how many there are.

What to do in an exam
If asked to name the extraembryonic membranes, give four: yolk sac, amnion, allantois, chorion
If asked for the three inside the shell that protect and service the embryo, give amnion, allantois, chorion
Always name them rather than counting them. A named list cannot be marked wrong on a count

Precocial and altricial young

Precocial Altricial
At hatching or birth Well developed. Eyes open, covered, mobile Poorly developed. Often blind and naked
Movement Can walk or swim almost at once Cannot walk
Feeding Can feed themselves soon after Must be fed
Warmth Largely self-sufficient Must be kept warm
Parental care needed Less More
South African example Ostrich chicks, running with the adults within days Most songbird chicks, naked in the nest

Finding 2: birds are not born

You will read that precocial species have young that can walk and feed themselves "soon after birth", and that altricial young must be fed and kept warm "for some time after birth".

Both definitions are applied to birds as well as mammals, and birds hatch. It is a small thing, and it is in a definition a learner has to reproduce.

Say "after hatching or birth". It costs three words and it is correct for both groups, which is what the definition is for.

Parental care

Group What the topic says they do
Birds Incubate the eggs, feed the chicks, keep them warm, teach them to feed
Mammals Feed the young on milk, keep them warm, teach them to feed

Milk is the one that defines the group. Every mammal does it and nothing else does, which makes it the safest answer in the topic.

Finding 3: "all birds and mammals care for their young"

That word "all" is doing damage, and South Africa has the counter-example.

Exception What it actually does
The greater honeyguide, a South African bird Lays its eggs in other birds' nests and leaves. The chick hatches early and kills the host's young. The honeyguide parents provide no care at all
Cuckoos The same strategy, which is called brood parasitism
Megapodes, the mound-builders Never sit on their eggs. They bury them in a mound of rotting vegetation and let the heat do the incubating, then take no further part. The chicks dig themselves out and leave

Mammals are a safer bet, because lactation makes some care unavoidable. Birds are not. The accurate version is that parental care is widespread in birds and universal in mammals, with brood parasites as the striking exception.

This is the third time this course has used the word "all" where it does not hold. When a sentence in a biology text begins with "all" or "only", it is worth a minute of class time to try to break it. More often than not, it breaks.

Finding 4: "parental care is rare in fish, amphibians and reptiles"

It is less common. It is not rare, and the best counter-example is a South African animal.

Animal The care it gives
The Nile crocodile Guards the nest for roughly three months. Hears the hatchlings calling from inside the eggs and digs them out. Carries them to the water in its mouth. Guards the creche for weeks afterwards
Mouthbrooding cichlids, found in South African waters Carry the eggs and then the fry inside the mouth, and will not feed while doing it
Some frogs Carry eggs or tadpoles on the back or in the mouth
Pythons Coil around the clutch and shiver to warm it

By any reasonable measure the crocodile is a more attentive parent than most birds. Teaching reptiles as uncaring leaves a learner unable to answer a question that uses a crocodile, and examiners like crocodiles.

What you should be able to do by the end

  • Compare external and internal fertilisation, including why the egg numbers differ
  • Define ovipary, ovovivipary and vivipary, and give an example of each
  • Say what separates ovovivipary from vivipary, which is nourishment, not location
  • Name the parts of the amniotic egg and give a function for each
  • Explain why the amniotic egg mattered for life on dry land
  • Compare precocial and altricial young, and link each to the amount of care
  • Give examples of parental care in birds, mammals and reptiles

Free worksheet and marking memo

Both free, no sign up, straight to the PDF.

  • Learner worksheet, 50 marks, covering fertilisation, the three development strategies, the amniotic egg, precocial and altricial young and parental care
  • Marking memorandum, with the five answers that look right and score nothing

Related practicals

Every Grade 12 Life Sciences topic

All ten are written up, and all ten are free. Each one gives the content, the assessed task where there is one, a learner worksheet and a marking memorandum.

Term Topic What it carries
1 DNA, the code of life The banana extraction, worth 6 marks, plus replication, transcription and translation
1 Mitosis and meiosis Both divisions stage by stage, the slide practical, and the contradiction that would make alleles impossible
1 Human reproduction The 20-mark sperm practical you can run for R58, gametogenesis, the four hormones and the placenta
1 Reproduction in vertebrates. You are reading this one Ovipary to vivipary, the amniotic egg, precocial and altricial young, and parental care
2 Genetics and inheritance Monohybrid and dihybrid crosses laid out the way marks are awarded, plus sex linkage
2 The nervous system and the senses The reflex arc, the reaction times investigation and the eye dissection, 80 marks between them
3 The endocrine system and homeostasis Negative feedback, thermoregulation and the skin, plus the 50-mark project
3 Phototropism and geotropism Auxins in root and shoot, and a free 25-mark rubric for an assessed task printed without one
3 Evolution by natural selection Evidence, Darwin, artificial selection, speciation and antibiotic resistance
3 and 4 Human evolution The hominid sequence, mitochondrial DNA, Out of Africa and the Cradle of Humankind